Kistrl vs Gmail: keep your Gmail address, change who gets in
Gmail lets anyone who knows your address into your inbox, and pays for itself with ads. Kistrl makes every new sender wait until you decide, and shows no ads. You do not have to choose. Forward Gmail to Kistrl, keep your address, and Gmail stays your complete archive.
Choose Kistrl if
Your Gmail inbox is mostly senders you never chose. You want to decide who gets in, sort mail by what it asks of you, and read without ads, while your Gmail address and archive stay exactly where they are.
Choose Gmail if
Your inbox is already calm, and free matters more to you than who can reach you.
| Kistrl | Gmail | |
|---|---|---|
| New senders | Wait at the Doorway. One decision per sender, with five answers: Inbox, Feed, Paper trails, Screened out or Spam. | Arrive in your inbox unless the spam filter catches them. You can block a sender only after their mail has arrived. |
| Sorting | You decide once per sender. Three places that behave differently. The Inbox for what needs you, the Feed for reading, Paper trails for receipts. | Google sorts each message into five tabs that all work the same way: Primary, Social, Promotions, Updates and Forums. |
| Ads | None. Your data is never sold. | Gmail shows ads. Google says it does not scan or read your messages to show them. |
| Mail you cannot answer yet | Reply later, Set aside and Bubble up are three separate marks. Focus & Reply lines up every answer you owe. Remind me if no reply watches questions you asked. | Snooze. |
| Undo send | Up to 60 seconds. | Up to 30 seconds. |
| Tracking and remote images | Every message opens in a sealed frame. Known trackers are blocked. Load other images through Kistrl Proxy, which hides your device, or only when you ask. | Images are shown automatically by default. Google says senders may know whether you opened an email. |
| Extra addresses | Random privacy addresses that do not reveal your username, and that you can block. Topic addresses with nothing to set up. | Plus addressing. Google notes that these aliases are not private. |
| Old mail that piles up | Recycling removes old newsletters, receipts and spam after an age you choose, by stream or by sender. It never touches unread or marked mail. | 15 GB, shared with the rest of your Google account. More with a paid Google One plan. |
| AI | Optional, part of the one plan, and off until you turn it on. Kistrl is complete without it. | Smart Compose is on by default. Gemini in Gmail needs an eligible Google Workspace or Google AI plan. |
| Offline | Recent mail and its attachments stay readable and searchable without a connection. | On a computer, in Chrome only. |
| Price | US$80 a year or US$8 a month. 100 GB. Mail, calendar, tasks, notes, habits, files and a website. 30 days free, no card. | Free. |
Gmail details checked on November 10, 2026. Kistrl is US$80 a year or US$8 a month, after 30 days free.
The short answer
Gmail treats every sender as invited. A shop you bought from once, an app that “keeps you posted” and your sister all arrive in the same list. Tabs move some of it aside, but the mail still arrives, and you still clean up after it.
Kistrl starts from the other end. The first time someone writes, their mail waits at the Doorway. You decide once, and everything they send later goes where you said.
You get this without leaving Gmail. Your address stays, your archive stays, and you can stop on any day.
Keep Gmail. Read it in Kistrl.
- Forward your Gmail to Kistrl. One setting in Gmail, about five minutes. Follow Keep Gmail, read it in Kistrl.
- Screen senders as they write. After two or three days most of your regular senders have a place, and your Inbox holds people and the things that need you.
- Answer from your Gmail address by connecting it for sending. Gmail’s own server sends the message, so it arrives from you with no “via” label.
Where Gmail falls short, and what Kistrl does
Anyone can reach your inbox
In Gmail, knowing your address is enough. Blocking works only after the mail has landed.
In Kistrl a new sender waits. You see who they are and what they sent, and you press a key from 1 to 5: Inbox, Feed, Paper trails, Screened out or Spam. The next waiting sender opens on its own. One rule can cover a whole domain, so everyone from one organisation lands in the same place. A week has few new senders, so this takes seconds.
Five tabs that all work the same way
Gmail’s tabs are five lists. Google chooses the tab, message by message.
Kistrl has three places, and you choose per sender. The Inbox keeps new mail above what you have already seen, and Catch up opens everything unread as one list you read from top to bottom. The Feed shows newsletters already open, as reading cards, and nothing in it asks for a reply. Paper trails joins an order, its receipt and its delivery into one timeline.
One kind of “later”
Gmail has snooze. Kistrl separates three things that snooze mixes up. Reply later records an answer you owe. Set aside keeps a ticket or an address close. Bubble up returns a conversation on the day you pick. Focus & Reply then shows every answer you owe, with the original on one side and your reply on the other. Remind me if no reply brings a conversation back when a question you asked goes unanswered.
Ads beside your mail
Gmail shows ads. Kistrl shows none and does not sell your data. Your subscription is the whole business.
Senders can see that you opened
Gmail shows images automatically, and Google says senders may know whether you opened an email.
In Kistrl every message opens in a sealed frame that cannot run scripts or submit forms. Known tracking resources are blocked. For the rest, choose Kistrl Proxy and the sender never sees your IP address or browser, or choose Block until I choose and nothing loads until you ask.
Aliases that give your address away
A Gmail plus address contains your real address. A Kistrl privacy address is random and does not reveal your username. Give each shop its own, and block it on the day spam starts. You then know which shop passed your address on.
Mail that piles up against a shared limit
Gmail’s 15 GB is shared with the rest of your Google account. In Kistrl, recycling removes old newsletters, receipts and spam after an age you choose, and never touches unread mail or anything you marked. The plan has room for years of mail besides.
More that comes with Kistrl
- A calendar with countdowns, tasks you can drop on a day, and away days that answer mail for you.
- Tasks, habits and notes in the same account, and a website you publish from your notes.
- Files: every attachment from senders you let in, searchable by what it says, with share links that expire.
- Optional AI that shows the sign-in code or the deadline an email brings. It is off until you turn it on.
- Apps for the browser, Mac, Windows, Linux, iPhone and Android, in English and French.
Nothing to lose by trying
- Your address stays. Everyone keeps writing to Gmail.
- Your archive stays, and stays complete. Gmail keeps its own copy of everything it forwards. Kistrl can also send copies to Gmail of mail that arrives at your Kistrl address.
- Kistrl never has access to your Gmail account. It receives what Gmail forwards, and nothing else.
- Stopping takes one setting. Turn forwarding off in Gmail.
- The trial is free for a month and needs no card.
Two things to know. Gmail does not forward what it marks as spam, so Gmail’s spam filter keeps working for you. A Gmail account from a school or employer may have forwarding turned off by its administrator.
When Gmail alone is enough
If your inbox is calm and free matters most, stay with Gmail as it is. If you only want to see what a screened inbox feels like, the steps above cost nothing and change nothing in Gmail.