Compare · Kistrl vs Proton Mail

Kistrl vs Proton Mail: an encrypted inbox still fills up

Proton Mail encrypts your mailbox so that Proton cannot read it. That does not stop mail from arriving, and it limits what the service can do for you. Kistrl makes new senders wait, sorts what you let in, and keeps your mail encrypted at rest in the European Union.

Choose Kistrl if

Your problem is too much mail from senders you never chose. You want it screened and sorted, with follow-up tools, room to keep it, and calendar, tasks and notes in one app.

Choose Proton Mail if

You need a mailbox that the provider itself cannot open. For that, choose Proton Mail.

Kistrl and Proton Mail, side by side
KistrlProton Mail
New sendersWait at the Doorway. One decision per sender, with five answers: Inbox, Feed, Paper trails, Screened out or Spam.Arrive in your inbox unless the spam filter catches them. You can block a sender or write a filter afterwards.
Newsletters and receiptsThe Feed shows newsletters open, as reading cards. Paper trails joins an order, its receipt and its delivery.A Newsletters view lists your mailing lists, with unsubscribe. Proton notes that the emails stay where they are.
Mail you cannot answer yetReply later, Set aside and Bubble up are three separate marks. Focus & Reply. Remind me if no reply. All in the one plan.Snooze and scheduled send, with custom times on paid plans only.
Undo sendUp to 60 seconds.Up to 20 seconds.
EncryptionEncrypted at rest with AES-256-GCM, at work and in transit. Not end-to-end, because Kistrl's servers sort and search your mail for you.Zero-access encryption for stored mail. End-to-end between Proton Mail users. Mail to and from other providers is not end-to-end encrypted unless you protect it with a password.
Storage and price100 GB. US$80 a year or US$8 a month. 30 days free, no card.1 GB on the free plan. 15 GB on Mail Plus, at US$4.99 a month list price. 500 GB on Proton Unlimited, at US$12.99 a month list price.
Extra addressesRandom privacy addresses and topic addresses. Your own domain in the plan.10 hide-my-email aliases on Free and Mail Plus. One custom domain on Mail Plus.
Forwarding your mail outIn the plan, to up to five verified addresses. After a paid year, your address keeps forwarding even if you leave.Needs a paid plan.
AIOptional and in the one plan. Off until you turn it on. It shows sign-in codes and deadlines, links receipts, and suggests replies when you ask.Proton Scribe, a writing assistant you turn on. Included in some plans.
Tracking and remote imagesA sealed frame for every message, known trackers blocked. Load other images through Kistrl Proxy, or only when you ask.Loaded and cached by Proton's servers, with a setting that blocks email tracking.
AppsBrowser, Mac, Windows, Linux, iPhone and Android.Browser, iPhone, Android, Windows and macOS. Linux in beta.

Proton Mail details checked on November 10, 2026. Kistrl is US$80 a year or US$8 a month, after 30 days free.

The short answer

Proton Mail and Kistrl both call themselves private, and they mean different things.

Proton Mail protects what is in your mailbox from Proton itself. Kistrl protects your attention and your address. A new sender cannot reach your Inbox without your yes. A shop gets an address you can block. A message cannot run scripts or report your device.

Encryption keeps a message secret. It does not stop the message from arriving. An encrypted inbox can still be full of shops, apps and strangers, and that is the problem Kistrl solves.

Where Proton Mail falls short, and what Kistrl does

Anyone can still reach your inbox

In Proton Mail, a new sender arrives unless the spam filter catches them. Blocking and filters come afterwards.

In Kistrl a new sender waits at the Doorway. You press a key from 1 to 5: Inbox, Feed, Paper trails, Screened out or Spam. The choice covers everything they send later, and one rule can cover a whole domain.

The newsletters stay in your inbox

Proton’s Newsletters view lists your mailing lists so you can unsubscribe. Proton notes that the emails themselves stay where they are.

In Kistrl a newsletter never enters the Inbox. It goes to the Feed, already open as a reading card, and nothing there asks for a reply. Receipts go to Paper trails, where an order, its receipt and its delivery join into one timeline.

A server that cannot read your mail cannot work on it

This is the trade. Because Kistrl can read your mail, it can sort it at the door, join receipts into timelines, search your mail and the contents of your files in one box, and, if you turn AI on, show the sign-in code or the deadline an email brings.

End-to-end covers less than it sounds

Proton’s end-to-end encryption applies between Proton Mail users. Mail from your bank, your shops and most of your contacts comes from other providers, and Proton explains that it is not end-to-end encrypted on the way. Subject lines are not either. What Proton always gives you is zero-access storage.

Kistrl says plainly what it does. Mail is encrypted at rest with AES-256-GCM, with keys kept apart from the data, on servers in Germany and Finland. Support tools cannot read it. It is not end-to-end encrypted.

Follow-up tools sit behind plans

In Proton Mail, custom snooze and send times need a paid plan. In Kistrl everything is in the one plan. Reply later, Set aside and Bubble up are three separate marks, Focus & Reply shows every answer you owe, and Remind me if no reply watches the questions you asked. Every send can be undone for up to a minute.

Counted aliases, counted gigabytes

Mail Plus has 15 GB, ten hide-my-email aliases and one custom domain. Kistrl’s plan has more room, as the table shows, random privacy addresses for every shop and sign-up, and your own domain with DNS set up in one click at Cloudflare, GoDaddy and IONOS.

Leaving costs extra

Forwarding your Proton mail to another address needs a paid plan. Kistrl forwards copies to up to five addresses as part of the plan. If you leave after a paid year, your Kistrl address keeps forwarding new mail to an address you choose, with no end date. Your mail never stops arriving.

More that comes with Kistrl

  • A sealed frame for every message, with known trackers blocked and a proxy that hides your device.
  • A calendar, tasks, habits, notes and files in one app, at one price, and a website from your notes.
  • Optional AI that is off until you turn it on, and sends requests only to services that keep nothing.
  • No ads, and your data is never sold.
  • English and French.

Nothing to lose by trying

The trial is free for a month and needs no card. On a paid Proton plan, forward your mail to the import-only address in Kistrl and screen senders for a week. To stop, turn forwarding off. Moving to a new email provider without losing mail covers a full move, including your domain.

When Proton Mail is the better choice

If the content of your stored mail must stay closed to everyone, including the company that stores it, choose Proton Mail. Kistrl does not offer that. Proton also has a free plan, and Kistrl does not.

Your next step

Moving to a new email provider without losing mailChanging email providers does not have to happen in one day. A gradual move, forward first and switch later, keeps every message arriving while you update your address.

See it in Kistrl

Questions

Is Kistrl end-to-end encrypted like Proton Mail?

No, and that is a choice. Kistrl sorts, filters and searches your mail on its servers, and to do that the servers have to read it. That is what makes the Doorway, Paper trails timelines and search inside files possible. Your mail is encrypted with AES-256-GCM where it is stored, with the keys kept apart from the data, and encrypted while it travels.

How much of my mail does Proton's end-to-end encryption cover?

Mail between two Proton Mail users. Proton explains that mail to or from other providers travels with ordinary transport encryption unless you protect it with a password, and that subject lines are not end-to-end encrypted. Stored mail is zero-access encrypted in all cases. Most everyday mail, from shops, banks and newsletters, comes from other providers.

Who at Kistrl can read my mail?

Support cannot. Kistrl's support tools show account facts only, and the database login they use cannot read mail, notes, files, contacts or calendars. The small group that runs the servers could reach the data, and uses that access to keep Kistrl running, never to read mail. The Security page says this in full.

Where does Kistrl store my mail?

On servers and in object storage in the European Union, in Germany and Finland. Mail you send to an address outside Kistrl passes through a delivery provider in the United States, as the privacy policy explains.

Can I try Kistrl with my Proton address?

On a paid Proton plan, yes. Forward your mail to the import-only address in Kistrl. Proton notes that forwarding to an address outside Proton turns off end-to-end encryption for the forwarded mail. Forwarding is not available on Proton's free plan.

Can I use both?

Yes, and some people do. A Proton address for the few conversations that must stay closed to everyone, and Kistrl for everyday mail, where the problem is volume and not secrecy.

More comparisons

Decide who gets in.

Pick a username and it becomes your Kistrl address. No card needed.