Kistrl vs HEY: the screened inbox, with more in the plan
Both make new senders wait and keep newsletters and receipts out of the inbox. Kistrl adds what HEY leaves out or sells separately. Privacy addresses, your own domain in the same plan, tasks and habits, a reminder when nobody answers, monthly billing, and French.
Choose Kistrl if
You want the screened inbox, and also aliases, your own domain without a second subscription, tasks and habits beside your mail, optional AI, or an interface in French.
Choose HEY if
You want a plan for a whole household, or you already live in HEY and nothing in the table matters to you.
| Kistrl | HEY | |
|---|---|---|
| New senders | Wait at the Doorway. The first decision is also the sorting decision, with five answers: Inbox, Feed, Paper trails, Screened out or Spam. A rule can cover a whole domain. | Wait in the Screener. You decide whether you want to hear from them, once per sender. |
| Newsletters and receipts | The Feed for reading. Paper trails for receipts, with an order, its receipt and its delivery joined in one timeline. | The Feed for newsletters. Paper Trail for receipts. |
| Mail you cannot answer yet | Reply later, Set aside and Bubble up. Focus & Reply. Remind me if no reply, for questions you asked. | Reply Later, Set Aside and Bubble Up. |
| Extra addresses | Topic addresses with nothing to set up, and random privacy addresses you can block. | HEY for You has no aliases. |
| Your own domain | In the same plan. DNS set up in one click at Cloudflare, GoDaddy and IONOS. | A separate product, HEY for Domains: US$12 per user a month. |
| Price for one person | US$80 a year, or US$8 a month if you prefer. 100 GB. 30 days free, no card. | US$99 a year, billed yearly only. 100 GB. 30 days free, no card. |
| Tasks and habits | Tasks you can plan on the calendar, with deadlines, countdowns and a timer. Habits that count good weeks. | Not on HEY's feature list. |
| Calendar, notes, files, website | All four. Notes are plain Markdown with version history and export. Files are searchable by their contents. | HEY Calendar, a journal and notes on contacts and threads, files, and the HEY World blog. |
| AI | Optional AI in the plan, off until you turn it on. It shows sign-in codes and deadlines and suggests replies when you ask. Or connect your own agent over MCP. | No AI built into the mailbox. You can connect ChatGPT, Claude or your own agents. |
| Tracking and remote images | Every message opens in a sealed frame. Known trackers are blocked. Load other images through Kistrl Proxy, or only when you ask. | Blocks spy pixels and tells you which service tried to track you. |
| Offline | Recent mail and attachments, and everything you marked, readable and searchable without a connection. | Parts of the mailbox. The Imbox, Reply Later and Set Aside. |
| Languages | English and French, including help. | English only. |
HEY details checked on November 10, 2026. Kistrl is US$80 a year or US$8 a month, after 30 days free.
The short answer
If you have used HEY, Kistrl will feel familiar. A new sender waits until you decide. Newsletters have a place for reading, receipts have a place for keeping, and “not now” has more than one meaning.
The difference is what the plan includes. HEY for You is one address, in English, billed once a year. Kistrl puts aliases, your own domain, tasks, habits and optional AI into one plan, lets you pay monthly, and speaks French.
Where HEY falls short, and what Kistrl does
One address, and no aliases
HEY for You has no aliases. Every shop and sign-up gets your real address.
Kistrl gives you topic addresses with nothing to set up: add +shop or .travel to your username. It also gives you random privacy addresses that do not reveal your username. Give each shop its own, and block it on the day spam starts.
Your own domain is a second subscription
In HEY a custom domain means HEY for Domains, at US$12 per user a month.
In Kistrl your own domain is part of the plan. At Cloudflare, GoDaddy and IONOS, Kistrl adds the DNS records in one click. Anywhere else it walks you through each record, checks them, and tells you when it is ready to receive. Custom-domain activation may not be switched on for your account yet. Settings tells you when that is the case.
Screening and sorting are two steps
The Screener asks whether you want to hear from someone. In Kistrl the Doorway asks where their mail belongs, so screening and sorting are one keypress, from 1 to 5. After each decision the next sender opens on its own. A rule for a whole domain places everyone from one organisation at once, and a contact with several addresses can send each one to a different place.
Nothing watches the questions you asked
Kistrl has the three marks you know, and adds Remind me if no reply. Choose it when you send. If nobody has answered by the day you picked, the conversation returns to your Inbox under No reply yet. An answer cancels the reminder, and an out-of-office does not count as one.
No tasks, no habits
A deadline in an email belongs on a list. Kistrl has tasks you can drop on a calendar day, with deadlines, countdowns and a timer, and habits that count good weeks and not streaks. With AI on, an email that sets you a deadline becomes a to-do linked back to the message.
English only, yearly only
HEY’s interface is in English, and HEY for You is billed once a year. Kistrl’s apps, site and help are in English and French, and you can pay by the month.
No AI of its own
HEY lets you connect outside agents. Kistrl does that too, over MCP, where an agent can write a draft but can never send or delete. It also has its own optional AI assistance. Turn it on and it shows the sign-in code an email brings, marks what needs an answer, and links receipts into timelines. It is off until you turn it on, and mail waiting at the Doorway is never sent to it.
More that comes with Kistrl
- Catch up opens every unread conversation as one list you read from top to bottom.
- Recycling removes old newsletters, receipts and spam after an age you choose.
- Files lists every attachment from senders you let in, and searches inside them.
- Notes in plain Markdown, with version history and export, and a website published from them.
- Stored in the European Union, encrypted at rest, with support tools that cannot read your mail.
Nothing to lose by trying
Both trials are free and need no card. Forward the same mailbox to each for a week and screen the same senders. Kistrl never needs access to the mailbox you forward from, and that mailbox stays as it was.
When HEY is the better choice
HEY has a Families plan for a household, and Kistrl has one plan for one person. HEY also names the tracking service behind each spy pixel, which Kistrl does not.