Kistrl vs Shortwave: an AI that reads everything, or a door
Shortwave puts an AI assistant in charge of a Gmail account, and keeps a copy of your mail to do it. Kistrl sorts mail by your own decision per sender, with AI off until you turn it on, and never signs in to your Gmail. It also works if you do not use Gmail at all.
Choose Kistrl if
You want to decide who reaches you, with AI as an option and not the engine. You do not want a second copy of your whole Gmail at another company. Or your mail is not Gmail.
Choose Shortwave if
You want an AI assistant that searches and writes across your whole Gmail history, and you want to start on a free plan.
| Kistrl | Shortwave | |
|---|---|---|
| New senders | Wait at the Doorway. One decision per sender, with five answers: Inbox, Feed, Paper trails, Screened out or Spam. | Arrive with everyone else. Splits, bundles and AI filters sort each message. |
| Who decides | You, once per sender. It works with AI off. | Bundles and AI filters, message by message. |
| AI | Optional and off until you turn it on. Requests go only to services that keep nothing. Mail at the Doorway is never sent. | The centre of the product. An assistant, AI search, AI filters and writing in your style. |
| Access to your mailbox | None. Gmail forwards mail to Kistrl. Kistrl never signs in to read your account. | Shortwave connects to your Gmail account and synchronises your mail to its own storage on Google Cloud. |
| Works with | Its own address, your own domain, and mail forwarded from any provider. | Gmail and Google Workspace accounts. Microsoft 365 and Exchange are not supported. |
| Price for one person | US$80 a year or US$8 a month. One plan with everything. 30 days free, no card. | Free with limited AI, 90 days of search history and a "Sent with Shortwave" signature. Pro: US$18 a month. |
| Newsletters and receipts | The Feed shows newsletters open, as reading cards. Paper trails joins an order, its receipt and its delivery. | Bundles for newsletters, promotions and travel, with delivery schedules. An AI filter can gather receipts. |
| Mail you cannot answer yet | Reply later, Set aside and Bubble up are three separate marks. Focus & Reply. Remind me if no reply. | Snooze, to-dos and stars. |
| Where your mail is kept | In Kistrl, encrypted at rest, on servers in the European Union. | In Gmail, with a copy at Shortwave. |
| Extra addresses | Random privacy addresses, topic addresses, and your own domain in the plan. | None. Shortwave uses your Gmail address. |
| Beyond mail | Calendar, tasks, habits, notes with a journal, a website from your notes, and files. | A calendar view, to-dos, and shared threads and comments for teams. |
| Apps | Browser, Mac, Windows, Linux, iPhone and Android. Recent mail readable offline. | Browser, Mac, Windows, iPhone and Android. |
Shortwave details checked on November 10, 2026. Kistrl is US$80 a year or US$8 a month, after 30 days free.
The short answer
Shortwave asks: what if an AI assistant ran your Gmail? Kistrl asks: what if strangers could not reach your inbox at all?
The first needs an AI to read all of your mail, and a copy of your mailbox at another company. The second needs one decision from you per sender. Kistrl is the second.
Where Shortwave falls short, and what Kistrl does
Sorting needs an AI to read your mail
Shortwave sorts each message with bundles and AI filters.
Kistrl asks you one question per sender, the first time they write. At the Doorway you press a key from 1 to 5: Inbox, Feed, Paper trails, Screened out or Spam. The choice covers everything they send later, and one rule can cover a whole domain. No model has to read your mail for this to work.
AI is the product, so it is always there
Every Kistrl account starts with AI assistance off, and reading, writing, searching and sending all work without it. Turn it on and it marks what needs an answer, links receipts into timelines, and shows the sign-in code or deadline an email brings. Requests go only to services that keep nothing and do not train on them. Mail waiting at the Doorway, screened out or in Spam is never sent.
A second copy of your whole mailbox
Shortwave connects to your Gmail account and synchronises your mail to its own storage.
Kistrl never signs in to your Gmail. Gmail forwards new mail, and that is all Kistrl receives. It is stored encrypted at rest, on servers in Germany and Finland, and Kistrl’s support tools cannot read it.
Gmail only
Shortwave works with Gmail and Google Workspace. Microsoft 365 and Exchange are not supported.
Kistrl gives you your own address, random privacy addresses for shops and sign-ups, and your own domain in the plan. It accepts mail forwarded from any provider.
The free plan signs your mail
Shortwave’s free plan limits AI and search history and adds “Sent with Shortwave” to your messages. Its personal paid plan is US$18 a month.
Kistrl has one plan, with nothing held back for a dearer one, and nothing added to your mail.
Your own agent, on your terms
If you want an assistant, bring the one you already use. Connect it to Kistrl over MCP and choose what it may read and change, from mail to tasks, notes and files. It can write a draft. It can never send or delete, and every change it makes can be undone.
More that comes with Kistrl
- Three kinds of “not now”: Reply later, Set aside and Bubble up, with Focus & Reply for every answer you owe.
- Remind me if no reply, for the questions you asked.
- A sealed frame for every message, with known trackers blocked and a proxy that hides your device.
- A calendar, tasks, habits, notes and files in the same account, and a website from your notes.
- Apps for the browser, Mac, Windows, Linux, iPhone and Android, in English and French.
Nothing to lose by trying
Follow Keep Gmail, read it in Kistrl. It takes about five minutes. Your Gmail address keeps working, Gmail keeps its own copy of every message, and switching forwarding off undoes everything. Shortwave can stay connected to the same account while you compare. The Kistrl trial is free for a month and needs no card.
When Shortwave is the better choice
If you want one built-in assistant that answers open questions across years of Gmail history, Shortwave does that. Kistrl starts with new mail, and leaves that job to the agent you connect.