Compare · Kistrl vs SaneBox

Kistrl vs SaneBox: a sorted folder, or a front door

SaneBox signs in to your mailbox and moves mail into folders by prediction, with features counted by plan. Kistrl never signs in to your mailbox. You forward to it, every new sender waits for your decision, and one plan includes everything. Your address and your old mailbox stay as they are.

Choose Kistrl if

You want to decide about each sender yourself, read newsletters and receipts in places made for them, give no service access to your mailbox, and get calendar, tasks and notes at one price.

Choose SaneBox if

Your mailbox cannot forward, as with many work accounts, or you will not leave the mail app you use now.

Kistrl and SaneBox, side by side
KistrlSaneBox
Access to your mailboxNone. You forward mail to Kistrl. It never signs in to your account.SaneBox signs in with your password or an OAuth token.
Who decidesYou, once per sender. Nothing is predicted.An algorithm that reads message headers, and that you train by moving mail between folders.
New sendersEvery new sender waits at the Doorway. Five answers: Inbox, Feed, Paper trails, Screened out or Spam.By default, mail from unknown contacts stays in your inbox. SaneScreener can hold first-time senders in a folder until you move them.
Newsletters and receiptsThe Feed shows newsletters open, as reading cards. Paper trails keeps receipts, with an order and its delivery joined.A SaneNews folder and a daily digest. A folder is a list in your mail app.
Price for one personUS$80 a year or US$8 a month. One plan with everything. 30 days free, no card.Snack: US$65 a year for one mailbox and two features. Lunch: US$109 a year for six features. Dinner, with every feature: US$319 a year.
AIOptional, off until you turn it on, and in the one plan.Optional, off until you turn it on, and only in the Dinner plan.
Mail you cannot answer yetReply later, Set aside, Bubble up, Focus & Reply, and Remind me if no reply.Snooze folders, and reminders when nobody answers.
Writing and sendingSend later, undo for up to 60 seconds, and a command palette.Depends on your mail app. SaneBox is not a mail app.
Tracking and remote imagesA sealed frame for every message, known trackers blocked, and a proxy that hides your device.Depends on your mail app. SaneBox does not change how messages open.
Extra addressesRandom privacy addresses, topic addresses, and your own domain in the plan.None. SaneBox does not provide addresses.
Beyond mailCalendar, tasks, habits, notes with a journal, a website from your notes, and files.Email only.

SaneBox details checked on November 10, 2026. Kistrl is US$80 a year or US$8 a month, after 30 days free.

The short answer

SaneBox and Kistrl fix the same problem from opposite sides.

SaneBox signs in to your mailbox, predicts which mail matters, and moves the rest into folders such as SaneLater and SaneNews. You keep your mail app, and the inbox is shorter.

Kistrl is the place you read. You forward your mail to it, new senders wait at the Doorway until you decide about them, and their mail goes where you said from then on. Your address does not change, and Kistrl never signs in to your mailbox.

Where SaneBox falls short, and what Kistrl does

A prediction you have to check

SaneBox guesses which mail matters, and you correct it by moving messages. When a guess is wrong, something you needed sits in SaneLater, so you still have to look there.

In Kistrl nothing is guessed. The first time someone writes, you press a key from 1 to 5 and choose where their mail belongs. The choice holds for everything they send, and one rule can cover a whole domain. A week has few new senders, so this takes seconds. See how to screen new senders.

It needs the keys to your mailbox

SaneBox works by signing in to your account with your password or an OAuth token.

Kistrl needs no access at all. Your provider forwards new mail, and that is the only thing Kistrl ever receives. To answer from your old address, you connect it for sending with an app password that is used only when you press Send.

Folders are still lists

SaneNews and SaneLater are folders, shown the way your mail app shows any folder.

Kistrl’s places work differently from each other. The Feed shows newsletters already open, as reading cards, and nothing in it asks for a reply. Paper trails joins an order, its receipt and its delivery into one timeline. The Inbox keeps new mail above what you have seen, and Catch up opens everything unread as one list.

Features counted by plan

The first SaneBox plan covers one mailbox and two features of your choice. Every feature, and the AI tools, means the Dinner plan at US$319 a year.

Kistrl has one plan with everything in it. Screening, the Feed, Paper trails, reminders, optional AI, and also a calendar, tasks, habits, notes and files.

It cannot protect how you read or write

SaneBox is not a mail app, so it changes nothing about how a message opens or how you send one.

Kistrl opens every message in a sealed frame that cannot run scripts, blocks known trackers, and can load images through a proxy so the sender never sees your device. Every send can be undone for up to a minute, and Focus & Reply shows every answer you owe beside the message it answers.

One address for everything

SaneBox does not give you addresses. Kistrl gives each shop a random privacy address that you block on the day spam starts, which stops the problem at its source.

Use Kistrl with the address you have

  1. Forward your mailbox to Kistrl and keep a copy at your provider. For Gmail, follow Keep Gmail, read it in Kistrl.
  2. Screen senders at the Doorway as they write. After two or three days most of your regular senders have a place.
  3. Connect your old address for sending, so your replies leave from it.

Nothing to lose by trying

Your old mailbox is never touched. It keeps its own copy of every message, and it stays your archive. Forwarding starts with new mail, so Kistrl begins clean. To stop, turn forwarding off. The trial is free for a month and needs no card.

When SaneBox is the better choice

If your mailbox cannot forward, which is common for work accounts, SaneBox can still connect to it. And if you will not change mail apps, SaneBox works inside the one you have.

Your next step

Keep Gmail, read it in Kistrl: forward your Gmail in five minutesYou do not have to give up your Gmail address. Forward it to Kistrl once, and new senders wait at the Doorway while your Gmail inbox stays quiet.

See it in Kistrl

Questions

Do I have to change my email address to use Kistrl?

No. Forward your current mailbox to the import-only address in Kistrl, under Settings, then Forwarding. People keep writing to the address they know, and your old mailbox keeps its own copy of everything.

Can I answer from my current address in Kistrl?

Yes. Connect it in Settings, then Sending, and choose it in the From field. Kistrl sends through your provider's own server, so the message arrives from your address with no "via" label. There are presets for Gmail, iCloud, Yahoo, Fastmail and Zoho, and none for Outlook or Microsoft 365 yet. Sending from another address may not be switched on for your account yet. Settings tells you when that is the case.

SaneBox has a screener too. What is different?

SaneScreener places mail from first-time senders in a folder, and you approve a sender by moving their mail to your inbox. That is a yes or a no. The Doorway asks where the sender belongs, with five answers, and each place then treats their mail differently. Screening is also how Kistrl works for everyone, and not one feature that counts against a plan.

Does Kistrl need my email password?

Not to receive mail. Your provider forwards to Kistrl, and Kistrl never signs in to read your mailbox. If you choose to send from your old address, you make an app password that Kistrl uses only when you press Send, and you can delete it at any time.

What happens to my old mailbox?

Nothing. Kistrl does not move, label or delete anything in it. It keeps receiving, and it stays your archive. If you stop using Kistrl, turn forwarding off and you are back where you started.

Can I use SaneBox and Kistrl together?

There is no reason to. SaneBox would sort mail inside the old mailbox, and Kistrl sorts it when it arrives. With Kistrl doing it, the SaneBox subscription is not needed.

More comparisons

Decide who gets in.

Pick a username and it becomes your Kistrl address. No card needed.