Compare · Kistrl vs Fastmail

Kistrl vs Fastmail: a mailbox you configure, or one that is already sorted

Fastmail and Kistrl are both paid, ad-free email services with your own domain. In Fastmail, screening senders is a rule you build yourself. In Kistrl it is how the mailbox works, with places for newsletters and receipts, follow-up tools, tasks, notes, habits and a website in the same plan.

Choose Kistrl if

You want sender screening and sorted mail without building rules, follow-up tools, and tasks, habits, notes and a website in the same account, with AI if you ever want it.

Choose Fastmail if

You want to read your mail in another mail app, or you need a plan for two people or a family.

Kistrl and Fastmail, side by side
KistrlFastmail
New sendersWait at the Doorway. One decision per sender, with five answers: Inbox, Feed, Paper trails, Screened out or Spam.Arrive in your inbox. Fastmail documents a rule you can build yourself, which moves mail from senders who are not contacts into a folder.
Newsletters and receiptsThe Feed shows newsletters open, as reading cards. Paper trails joins an order, its receipt and its delivery.Folders and rules that you set up yourself.
Mail you cannot answer yetReply later, Set aside and Bubble up are three separate marks. Focus & Reply. Remind me if no reply.Snooze.
SendingSend later, and undo for up to 60 seconds.Scheduled send and undo send.
Storage100 GB for mail and files.60 GB on the Individual plan: 50 GB for mail and 10 GB for files.
Price for one personUS$80 a year or US$8 a month. 30 days free, no card.US$60 a year or US$6 a month. A trial of up to 30 days.
Beyond mailCalendar, tasks, habits, notes with a journal, a website from your notes, and files searchable by their contents.Calendar, contacts and file storage.
AIOptional AI in the plan, off until you turn it on. It shows sign-in codes and deadlines and links receipts. Or connect your own agent over MCP.No AI in the mailbox. You can connect your own AI tools over MCP.
Tracking and remote imagesA sealed frame for every message, known trackers blocked. Load other images through Kistrl Proxy, or only when you ask.Images are always loaded by Fastmail's servers on your behalf in its web and mobile apps.
Extra addressesRandom privacy addresses, topic addresses, and your own domain in the plan, with DNS set up in one click at Cloudflare, GoDaddy and IONOS.Masked Email, aliases, and your own domain in the Individual plan.
Ads and your dataNo ads. Your data is never sold. AI services keep nothing and do not train on it.No ads. Your data is not sold, and Fastmail says it has never trained AI on customer data.
LanguagesEnglish and French, including sign-up and help.21 interface languages, including French. Sign-up, help and support are in English only.

Fastmail details checked on November 10, 2026. Kistrl is US$80 a year or US$8 a month, after 30 days free.

The short answer

Fastmail and Kistrl agree on the basics. You pay, so there are no ads. Your domain is yours. Your mail is not the product.

They differ in who does the work. Fastmail gives you a classic mailbox and the parts to shape it: folders, rules, masked addresses. Kistrl arrives already shaped. New senders wait at the Doorway, and the mail you let in lands in the Inbox, the Feed or Paper trails.

Where Fastmail falls short, and what Kistrl does

Screening is a rule you build yourself

Fastmail’s own help shows how to make a screener from a rule: mail from anyone who is not a contact goes to a folder, and you approve a sender by adding them to your contacts.

In Kistrl there is nothing to build. Every new sender arrives at the Doorway, with who they are and what they sent. You press a key from 1 to 5, and the next sender opens on its own. One rule can place a whole domain, and a contact with several addresses can send each one to a different place.

Everything you let in lands in one list

Fastmail has no ready-made places for kinds of mail. You make folders and write the rules that fill them.

In Kistrl the decision at the Doorway is the sorting. The Feed shows newsletters already open, as reading cards, and nothing in it asks for a reply. Paper trails joins an order, its receipt and its delivery into one timeline. The Inbox keeps new mail above what you have seen, and Catch up opens everything unread as one list.

Snooze is the only “later”

Kistrl has three marks. Reply later records an answer you owe. Set aside keeps a ticket or an address close. Bubble up returns a conversation on the day you pick. Focus & Reply shows every answer you owe beside the message it answers, and Remind me if no reply brings a conversation back when a question you asked goes unanswered.

Mail, calendar, contacts, and little else

Kistrl adds tasks you can drop on a calendar day, with deadlines, countdowns and a timer. It adds habits that count good weeks, notes in plain Markdown with a journal and version history, and a website published from those notes. Files lists every attachment from senders you let in and searches inside them.

Less room

Fastmail’s Individual plan has 60 GB, of which 50 GB is for mail. Kistrl’s one plan has more, as the table shows, and recycling clears old newsletters, receipts and spam after an age you choose.

No AI, even if you want it

Fastmail has chosen to have no AI in the mailbox. Kistrl gives you the choice. Its AI assistance is off until you turn it on, and then it shows the sign-in code or deadline an email brings, marks what needs an answer, and links receipts into timelines. If you want none, leave it off and nothing runs. Both services let you connect your own agent over MCP.

French stops at the interface

Fastmail’s interface is in 21 languages, and its sign-up, help and support are in English. Kistrl’s apps, site and help are in English and French.

Nothing to lose by trying

In Fastmail, add a rule for all messages that sends a copy to your import-only address in Kistrl (Settings, then Forwarding). Your Fastmail mailbox is not changed. Screen senders for a week. To stop, delete the rule. The Kistrl trial is free for a month and needs no card.

To move for good, including your domain, follow Moving to a new email provider without losing mail. Kistrl checks every DNS record and waits for Ready to receive before you switch any mail.

When Fastmail is the better choice

Fastmail has plans for two people and for families, and Kistrl has one plan for one person. And if you want to read your mail in another mail app, Fastmail supports that and Kistrl does not.

Your next step

Moving to a new email provider without losing mailChanging email providers does not have to happen in one day. A gradual move, forward first and switch later, keeps every message arriving while you update your address.

See it in Kistrl

Questions

Can I build a screener in Fastmail with rules?

You can build half of one. Fastmail's help describes a rule that moves mail from anyone who is not in your contacts into a folder, and you approve a sender by adding them as a contact. That is a holding folder. The Doorway also asks where an approved sender belongs, opens the next sender for you, takes one key per decision, and can place a whole domain at once.

Can I try Kistrl without leaving Fastmail?

Yes. Add a Fastmail rule that sends a copy of all messages to your import-only address in Kistrl. New mail then arrives in both, and your Fastmail mailbox stays as it is. Kistrl has a sending preset for Fastmail, so you can answer from your Fastmail address. Sending from another address may not be switched on for your account yet.

Can I move my own domain from Fastmail to Kistrl?

Yes. Add the domain in Kistrl under Settings, then Domains. At Cloudflare, GoDaddy and IONOS, Kistrl adds the DNS records in one click. Elsewhere it shows each record, checks it, and tells you when it is ready to receive, before you switch any mail. Custom-domain activation may not be switched on for your account yet. Settings tells you when that is the case.

Which one is more private?

They are close. Both are paid, show no ads and do not sell data, and neither is end-to-end encrypted. Kistrl stores your mail in the European Union, encrypted at rest, and its support tools cannot read it. Kistrl also gives every message a sealed frame that cannot run scripts or submit forms.

What happens to my mail if I stop paying for Kistrl?

It keeps arriving. The account becomes read-only, and you can still read, export and delete everything. Once you have paid for a year in total, your Kistrl address keeps forwarding new mail to an address you choose, with no end date.

Does Kistrl work with other mail apps, like Apple Mail or Thunderbird?

Kistrl is used through its own apps, in the browser, on Mac, Windows and Linux, and on iPhone and Android. The Doorway, the Feed and Paper trails only exist there. If reading in another mail app matters most, Fastmail is the better fit.

More comparisons

Decide who gets in.

Pick a username and it becomes your Kistrl address. No card needed.