Email on your own domain: what to set up, and how to avoid the usual mistakes
An address on your own domain stays yours when you change email service. Setting it up means adding a few DNS records in the right order. Here is what each one does and where people go wrong.
An address at a provider’s domain belongs to that provider. If you leave, the address stays behind, and you must tell everyone your new one.
An address on a domain you own, such as you@yourname.com, moves with you. You change a few records, and the same address delivers to a different service. Nobody who writes to you sees a difference.
The part that stops most people is DNS: the list of records that tells the internet where your domain’s services are.
The records email needs
There are four kinds. You do not need to understand them in depth, only what each is for.
- An ownership record proves to the email service that the domain is yours. It changes nothing else.
- MX records say which servers receive mail for the domain. Changing these moves your incoming mail.
- SPF and DKIM records let other mail servers check that a message from your domain is real. Without them, your mail often goes to spam.
- A DMARC record tells other servers what to do with a message that fails those checks.
SPF, DKIM and DMARC in plain words explains the last three.
The right order
- Add the ownership record first. It is safe. Your website and your current email keep working.
- Add the SPF, DKIM and DMARC records.
- Wait until the new service confirms that it can receive mail for your domain.
- Then change the MX records. Mail starts to arrive at the new service. The change can take some hours to reach every server.
- Send a test in each direction before you tell anyone.
Five common mistakes
Changing MX records too early. If the new service is not ready, mail sent during the gap can bounce. MX records always go last.
Two SPF records. A domain must have only one SPF record. If you already have one, add the new service to it. A second record makes both fail.
Deleting website records. Email setup does not need you to touch the records for your website. Leave the A and CNAME records as they are.
Leaving the old MX records in place. If old and new MX records are both present, some mail goes to each service. Remove the old ones when you add the new ones.
Forgetting the old mailbox. Mail that arrived before the change stays at the old service. Forward or export it before you close that account.
Check where your DNS is hosted
Your DNS is often hosted where you bought the domain, but not always. Before you start, find out which company holds the records. That company’s control panel is where the records go.
In Kistrl
Open Settings, then Domains, add your domain and create your first address on it.
If your DNS is at Cloudflare, GoDaddy or IONOS, Kistrl adds the records for you in one click. You copy nothing by hand. At any other provider, Kistrl shows each record and takes you through it step by step.
Checks run automatically with both methods. Kistrl shows Ready to receive before you change any MX record, and if something is wrong, such as two SPF records, it says which record to fix and how. Your website’s records stay unchanged.
Custom-domain activation may not be switched on for your Kistrl service yet. Settings tells you when that is the case; you can save a domain and wait before you change any records. See Custom domains.
Your domain, with a deliberate cutover.
Add your domain, publish the records your own account shows, and move receiving over only when everything is ready.
Prove ownership.
Add the exact ownership record supplied by your own account.
Check sending records.
Use the SPF, DKIM and DMARC values shown for the domain, not values copied from a screenshot.
Switch receiving last.
Change MX records when the account says Ready to receive. Keep the old mailbox available during the change.